What To Do When a New Team Member Shows Their True Colours

What To Do When a New Team Member Shows Their True Colours ← All articles

You brought someone into your salon or clinic with high hopes. The interview went well, they had the right qualifications, and they seemed friendly enough. Then week two arrives. They are late again. They rolled their eyes when a client asked for something slightly different. They treat the back room like their own private lounge and their phone is alarmingly glued to their hand.

You are sitting there wondering if you made a mistake. You feel foolish for trusting your instincts during the interview. More importantly, you are unsure whether to say something now or give them more time to settle in. This is one of the most stressful moments in running a team because the stakes are high. A bad hire costs money,sure, but keeping someone who does not fit can cost you a heck of a lot more.

Why early signs matter more than you think

We often tell ourselves that people need time to adjust. That is true for skills and I guess, to an extent, for getting used to new routines. It is less true for character and attitude. If someone is consistently late, dismissive of clients, or disrespectful of your standards in the first few weeks, they are usually showing you who they really are under pressure. And this at a stage of their career when they should be out to impress.

Ignoring these signs because you do not want to seem harsh (or because recruitment if flippin' tough right now) only makes things worse. The new team member learns that your rules are flexible. Your existing staff see that standards have slipped. And you end up managing a problem that has grown too large to fix with a quiet word. Addressing behaviour early is actually the kindest thing you can do for all involved.

Separate skill from attitude

Before you make any decisions, check what exactly is going wrong. If they are struggling with the booking system or the product range, that is a training issue. You can fix that with clear instruction and patience. I have seen brilliant therapists who just needed a more robust onboarding process to feel confident.

If the issue is attitude, that is different. Arriving late shows they do not respect your time. Snapping at a client shows they do not understand your service values. These are not problems you can train out of them quickly. When I work with salon owners on my coaching programmes, we always look at this distinction first. Skills can be taught. Values must be shared and lived.

Use the probation period properly

The probation period exists for a reason. It's your safety net. If you have not already, read up on how to structure hiring correctly so you are protected from the start in How Do I Hire Salon Employees the Right Way?. Assuming you have a proper probation clause, you have the right to check in formally.

One mistake I see again and again is people treating the probation as a deadline. Don't wait until the end of the period to bring up concerns or even to terminate things early. You should be touching base with your new recruit weekly, anyway. State clearly what you expected and what you are seeing. Use specific examples rather than general impressions. Tell them exactly what needs to change for them to pass probation. This removes any ambiguity and gives them a fair chance to improve, and if things don't work out, it is much less of a shock.

How to have the difficult conversation

Keep it calm and factual. Choose a quiet time when you are not rushing between appointments. Start by stating your purpose: you want them to succeed, but you need certain standards met. Mention the specific incident, such as being twenty minutes late on Tuesday or speaking rudely to a client on Thursday.

Avoid emotional language. Don't label them as lazy or difficult. Just point out that their actions do not meet the salon's requirements. Ask for their perspective, but stay firm on the outcome you need. If they cannot meet your basic standards of punctuality and professionalism, no amount of coaching will fix it.

When to let them go

If the behaviour continues after you have spoken to them, make the decision. Keeping someone who undermines your business is a drain on your energy and your bottom line. It also signals to your good staff that poor performance is tolerated. You owe it to them to protect the environment and culture you have built.

Ending employment during probation is straightforward if you follow the terms you agreed upon. Give notice, collect company property, and part ways professionally. Don't burn bridges unnecessarily, but don't feel guilty for protecting your business. A salon runs on trust and consistency. If those are missing from day one, they will not appear by month three.

What to do this week

If you have a new team member who is causing concern, book a fifteen-minute meeting with them today. Prepare three specific points you need to discuss. Make it clear that these are non-negotiable for their continued employment. Watch how they respond. If they become defensive or dismissive, you likely have your answer. If they listen and commit to changing, set a follow-up review in one week.

Trust your instincts, but back them up with facts. You built this business to serve clients well and provide a good workplace for your team. Anyone who threatens that foundation does not belong in it.


Phil Jackson is a salon business coach and the founder of Build Your Salon. He spent over twenty years running his own salon before moving into coaching, and works with salon owners across the UK and beyond through his programmes Salon Spark, Ultimate Clarity, and the Evil Genius Retreat.

Phil Jackson — Salon Business Coach

Phil Jackson

Phil Jackson is a salon business coach and the founder of Build Your Salon. He spent over twenty years running his own salon before moving into coaching, and works with salon owners across the UK and beyond through his programmes Salon Spark, Ultimate Clarity, and the Evil Genius Retreat.

Ready to work with a coach who'll tell you what you need to hear?

Find out more about Phil's programmes and how to get started.

Find out more →